Continuing the blog serialisation of my popular X-Pro Series lust/hate/love story:
Part 65: The X-Pro2 Review: Fujifilm: Seeing in Colour and Greyscale
This will be the first in a (loosely) connected series about the look of your work, why we chose to do things and what outside influences guide our hand.
There are many reasons why us Fuji folk are happy with our camera choice!
You can easily swap between different ways of using the camera, automated exposure or full manual, no PASM dials for us!
Fujifilm has a lot of know-how when it comes to lenses, and Fuji glass is held in high regard. They even give us some choices when it comes to focal lengths, big 23 or little 23, 56, 50 and 60, even in the zooms – 18-55 or 16-55.
Not to mention the physical cameras themselves, X-T2 or X-Pro2, sure the image pipeline is the same, but the cameras are very different. We also get slightly less higher spec’d versions of the same image pipeline, eg X-T2 or X-T20
So chances are; you’re picking up a camera and lens combo that works for you.
But of course, what’s Fujifilm truly known for? As ever the clue is in the title – Film!
We really do get a large array of styles to chose from.
Colours ranging from low saturation to high, a set of Black and White look (with filters) and a set of Monochrome look (with filters)
These ‘film simulations’ are no longer the preserve of SOOC Jpegs either. Most of the RAW editors now offer them too, and for the ones that don’t, generally some independent talent has created them and given them away for free.
Yup, we’ve got it good 🙂
The choice between black and white and colour photography can be confusing.
How often do we see people on the forums and Facebook groups posting 2 images and asking
“hey guys do prefer the mono or the colour version of this shot?”
And (say) 20 people answer, and the poster gets 21 different opinions 🙂
There’s even a school of thought that one should decide early on, if one is a black and white or a colour photographer!
Pick one. Stick to it.
(Not a view I personally subscribe too, but it does exist and if you’re someone who’s exclusively adopted one medium, then I admire your Zen as well as your images !!)
I would say that I’m predominantly a colour shooter (we’ll go through why in a later article)
But I don’t discount black and white – not a bit of it.
There’s also endless rhetoric and opinion (he says; typing out a rhetoric/opinion based article ;D)
Monochrome captures the soul or accept the challenge of colour
Again…. I’m not personally convinced… And it’s even slightly complicated by the difference between black and white and monochrome. Monochrome is technically one shade (if could even be a colour!) used in different densities to achieve the image, whereas black and white is a greyscale. SLIGHTLY TONGUE IN CHEEK, but I think in the digital age, when viewed on screen we can say that a black and white is erm black and white, while a monochrome is a black and white that’s a bit silvery 🙂 and yes, I’m expecting someone to write in and correct me on that 🙂 🙂
Somethings one does tend to personally prefer in one look or another
But it’s up to you to decide, it’s up to you to chose. People can’t really do it for you IMO…
So on that note; and I CANNOT STRESS ENOUGH I’M NOT ASKING YOU TOO CHOSE FOR ME, I thought I’d give you 3 shots this week, each in colour and black and white
I’m doing this not only to highlight the difference each style makes to the image, but also for my own eye…
I would of chosen colour for each of these. I only made the black and whites when I got the idea for this article!
Like I said – I’m predominantly a colour shooter, but I don’t want to rule anything out, so sometimes it pays to try different looks.
I was also curious to see how my social media follows would react (quite possibly to unfollow me, for posting so many shots at once 🙂 )
But let’s start with my own views (which are just that – so YMMV)
I think the scooter shot (“Somewhere to Go”) is the strongest and that it works equally well in either format.
The building site shot (“A Big Hole”) I feel is best served in colour, it’s a little flat in black and white, but also the colour version ‘speaks’ to me in a more positive way, we can rebuild, whereas in black and white, I get more the sense of destruction
The shot of the street (“Lost”) I can make a case for each, it kinda pops a bit more in black and white, but the figure stands out better in colour, and his bright coloured top ties into the 2 colours that are the door and window of the building
But, let’s hand it over to my IG followers, after all what do I know – I’m just the photographer 🙂 🙂
Using nothing more than the amount of ‘likes’ the results are:
Somewhere to Go – more popular in black and white
A Big Hole – more popular in black and white
Lost – more popular in colour
So, should I shoot more in black and white…? Maybe I should…
“Why Adam, because of the penchant of your social media follows?”
No, because I feel more comfortable in colour, it probably means I should get out of that comfort zone a little more!
So what about you?
Do you like both colour and greyscale in your own work, or just stick to one or the other?
And in either case, why?
Let me know – comment or write in, I’m always enthralled to have conversations about creativity.
Anyway, here’s the shots in question:
In case it’s of interest, the colour shots are based around the Pro Neg Std film simulation, and the black and whites are true greyscales, as I’ve de-saturated the colour images, making dark/light changes to various colour channels as per my tastes.
A lot of time and effort goes into this site.. Hopefully it’s helped you? Perhaps you’d consider helping me?
One way you could help me is if you want to buy from Amazon, if you do so using the links below, then I will receive a small percentage of your expenditure, and you will pay NO MORE than you would have paid anyway.
If there’s a different product you’re considering, then perhaps you’d drop me a line and I can send you an associate link for it?
Another way you could help, is by making a donation. The donate button can be found on the link below
Thank You Very Much!